Critical Uncertainties

Activity

Liberating Structures, Ongoing engagement

Critical Uncertainties

Autumm Caines

Maha Bali

Engage everyone in making sense of profound challenges. Use to address difficult or confusing topics.

ACTIVITY PURPOSE

Develop strategies for operating in a range of plausible yet unpredictable futures (as described in http://www.liberatingstructures.com/30-critical-uncertainties/).

Please note that the video above was developed for a summer 2020 professional development activity called DigPINS – it was not created for this particular resource, so there is mention of a synchronous session and things to sign up for – this was part of the summer 2020 course.

USEFUL FOR

According to liberatingstructures.com, “you can help a diverse group quickly test the viability of current strategies and build its capacity to respond quickly to future challenges. This Liberating Structure prepares a group for strategy making. It does not produce a plan to be implemented as designed but rather builds resilience: the capacity to actively shape the system and be prepared to respond to surprise. This means being better able to see different futures unfolding, better prepared to act in a distributed fashion, and more ready to absorb disruptions resiliently.”

PREPARATION

Spaces for participants to list uncertainties and create axis to explore quadrants.

INSTRUCTIONS

The below is text adapted for virtual use, taking text mostly from the original description here: http://www.liberatingstructures.com/30-critical-uncertainties/

Whole group: Invite participants to individually make a list of uncertainties they face by asking, “In your/our operating environment, what factors are impossible to predict or control their direction?” 5 minutes.
Prioritize the most critical factors by asking, “Which factors threaten your/our ability to operate successfully?” 10 minutes.
Based on the group’s history and experience, select the two most critical and most uncertain (X and Y). 5 minutes. This step can occur as a whole group with voting, or can be done in smaller groups of 4-5 with each group voting for what interests them.
Create a grid (e.g. on Google slides) with two axes—X & Y—with a “more of <— —> less of” continuum for the factor to be represented on each axis. For example, for the X axis, if the number of new products is a critically uncertain factor, one end of the X axis is a large number of new products and the other is no new products. Repeat for the Y factor and axis. For instance, if patent protection is a critical factor, one end of the Y axis is strong patent protection and the other is no patent protection. Four quadrants are created. See example below. 5 minutes.
Groups can be split in different ways. Groups may be split up that they work on different quadrants while the whole group are working on the same topic; or different groups can be responsible for all four quadrants with any combination of axes. While working on quadrants, participants are encouraged to creatively name and write a thumbnail scenario for the quadrants. 10 minutes.
The four groups share their scenarios briefly. 2 minutes each.
Each group brainstorms three strategies that would help the group operate successfully in the scenario that it has described (this might mean groups choose the strategies that would work in different quadrants, given uncertainties, and prioritize this strategy for its versatility across critical uncertainties). 10 minutes.
The four groups share their strategies briefly. 2 minutes each.
The whole group sifts results to identify which strategies are robust (strategies that can succeed in multiple quadrants) and which are hedging (strategies that can succeed in only one scenario but protect you from a plausible calamity). The balance of strategies can succeed only in one scenario. 10 minutes.
Each small group debriefs with What, So What, Now What? 10 minutes.
The four groups share their debriefs and the whole group makes first-steps decisions about their Now What. 10 minutes.

DURATION

Synchronously, this could take up to two hours. With asynchronous components, you could take more time to reflect asynchronously, and the synchronous session can be 45 minutes, or so, in breakout rooms, before regrouping.

ADAPTATIONS AND EXAMPLES

It is meant to be fully synchronous, but in the video above, it is divided up into synchronous and asynchronous components. You can pair up some steps with other Liberating Structures such as “wicked questions” for the axes of uncertainty.

You can choose to have all groups use the same two axes, or you can allow (as we did) different groups to focus on different axes that they choose together.

TECHNICAL REQUIREMENTS

Some space for discussing different uncertainties that we care about (like a Google Doc) and some way for people to vote for ones.

Some space for collaborative visualization like Google Slides.

Breakout rooms to work in small groups.

USEFUL RESOURCES

Critical Uncertainties as described on the Liberating Structures website: http://www.liberatingstructures.com/30-critical-uncertainties/.

Watch Video

ABOUT

Educator prep: None
Student prep: None
Asynchronous
Video conferencing, Breakout rooms, Shared online space
Duration: 30+ mins

This activity is one of a series of activities from Equity Unbound, focused on equitable online community building.

Find out more

Do you have an activity that you would like to suggest?

Do you have feedback or suggestions?

More activities

Learning path

Community Building Online

by Maha Bali

Curated Activities

Reflective Activities

Curated Activities

Guidance and help

Curated Activities

Ongoing engagement

Curated Activities

Liberating Structures

Curated Activities

Setting the tone activities

Curated Activities

Warm up activities

Curated Activities

Introductory activities

Activity

Fast Friends

by Maha Bali

Activity

Two-minute paper

by Maha Bali

Activity

Creativity Booster: 16 Squares

by Diana Varma

Activity

Creativity Booster: An Ode to the Other Hand

by Diana Varma

Activity

Creativity Booster: 5 Senses

by Diana Varma

Activity

Creativity Booster: Yes, Let’s!

by Diana Varma

Activity

Create a Fake Photo Group Assignment

by Maha Bali

Activity

What We Don’t Know About Each Other

by Noha El-Rawy

Activity

Share Music and Create a Class Playlist

by Maha Bali

Activity

Would You Rather?

by Frank Tontala

Activity

Creating Escape Room Experience For Students

by Karina Alonso

Activity

I Wish My Students/Teacher Knew…

by Amena Magdy

Activity

Using Metaphors to Express Thoughts

by Sayyed Daifallah

Activity

Using Dominoes in Teaching

by Ahmed Gebaly

Activity

Desert Island Songs

by Isabel Rodriguez

Activity

The Shape of You

by Sarah Neuwirth

Activity

Words From Your Names

by Ahmed Shalaby

Activity

What Can You Do With A…?

by Noha El-Sebai

Activity

Choose a Plant

by Jen Alexander

Activity

Which Picture Best?

by Flower Darby

Activity

Imaginary Buffet (or Potluck)

by Maya Hey

Activity

PowerPoint Karaoke

by Maha Bali

Activity

Office Hour Scheduling via Google Calendar

by Fikry Boutros

Activity

Tiny Tales

by Laura Gibbs

Activity

Cognitive/exam Wrappers for Metacognition

by Maha Bali

Activity

Self-assessment Tool (of social justice in your teaching) from DISCs (Disciplines Inquiring into Societal Challenges)

by Maha Bali

Activity

Language Portrait

by Francesca Helm

Activity

Lost in Translation

by Francesca Helm

Activity

Wheel of Life for Student Self-help

by Maha Bali

Activity

Alternative Approaches to Grading

by Maha Bali

Activity

Thick Greetings

by Maha Bali

Activity

Estimate workload

by Maha Bali

Activity

Simple Metacognitive Activities

by Maha Bali

Activity

Tiny Demons/Drawing Monsters

by Lyse Edwards

Activity

Start/Stop/Continue

by Maha Bali

Activity

Survey students early in the semester: Pre-Course Survey

by Maha Bali

Activity

Pass the Paper

by Sarah Silverman

Activity

Gratitude Journal

by Maha Bali

Activity

15% solutions

by Maha Bali

Checklist / tool

Karen Ray Costa’s Trauma-Aware Teaching Checklist

Article

Getting Feedback From Students Mid-Semester

Resource

Loglines

Activity

Appreciative Interviews

by Maha Bali

Activity

Pop-up Psychogeography Journey Journal

by Sarah-Jane Crowson

Guide

Some Safety Considerations for Online Community Building

by Kate Bowles

Activity

While We Wait

by Jasmina Najjar

Activity

What kind of animal are you?

by Irene Maweu

Activity

Two by Three by Bradford

by Sarita Shukla

Activity

Troika Consulting – Adaptation for Class Community Building

by Maha Bali

Activity

TRIZ

by Maha Bali

Video discussion

Trauma-Informed Pedagogy & How is Your Heart?

by Mays Imad

Activity

Tour of Where You Are

by Patrice Prusko

Activity

Third Places for Ongoing Community Building

by Maha Bali

Activity

Theater of the Oppressed: Opposites

by Tina Pippin

Activity

Theatre of the Oppressed: Image Theatre

by Maha Bali

Activity

Teaching Ethics with Theatre of the Oppressed and Liberating Structures

by Maha Bali

Activity

Surrealist Free Drawing Introductions

by Autumm Caines

Activity

Studio visits

by Mia Zamora

Activity

Structured Dialogues

by Sherri Spelic

Activity

Share an object from home

by Maha Bali

Activity

Room 101

by Jasmina Najjar

Activity

Purpose to Practice

by Maha Bali

Activity

Pass the Ball & How Do You Make Rice?

by Autumm Caines

Activity

Meditation

by Nadine Aboulmagd

Activity

Wild Tea / Mad Tea

by Maha Bali

Activity

Introductions: Story of Your Name

by Patrice Prusko

Activity

Human Scavenger Hunt

by Susan D. Blum

Activity

Four Ideas for Checking In

by Maha Bali

Activity

Daily Creates

by Mia Zamora

Activity

Conversation Cafe

by Maha Bali

Activity

Collaborative Storytelling

by Jasmina Najjar

Activity

Collaborative Literature Review Matrix

by Jasmina Najjar

Activity

Authentic Open Letter/Video Addressing Students

Activity

Asynchronous & Synchronous Introductions

by Mia Zamora

Activity

9 Whys of Liberating Structures

by Michael Weinraub

Activity

Spiral Journal

by Maha Bali

Activity

Annotate the Syllabus

by Remi Kalir