Activity

Making Large Classes Feel Smaller: Classroom Discussion Strategy

Jay Howard

Jay Howard

This strategy helps generate class discussion and is particularly helpful in high enrolment courses. 
Click here to view the video transcript

We’ve mentioned two strategies for engaging students in the college classroom. The use of a Think-Pair-Share, and limiting who can speak. We also want to talk about those large courses. How can you make a large enrollment course feel smaller so that students will engage in classroom discussion? Of course, you can use the strategy in a large class. That makes perfect sense. And then perhaps asking people to volunteer their partner, or randomly calling on pairs of students to speak up. But a better strategy, I think, is to organise students in semester long small groups or teams.

Now a good strategy for this, I’m a sociologist, in my case, we could name the teams after famous sociologists. So there’s Team Marx, and Team Durkheim, and Team Weber, and Team Mills, and so on. So, you know, pick a name, whatever fun sort of thing so students begin to recognise that’s my team. My team has a name. And then there are five to eight students in each of those teams. And in these large enrollment courses, students are required to sit close to one another during class. And while the class might be predominantly lecture because of the large size, at some point or points during the class session, you take a break from the lecture and say, it’s time for us to have conversations in our teams.

So just as with Think-Pair-Share, you give them a compelling question that can be addressed from multiple different angles, and provide different insights. And have the students discuss the question in their teams. Now, keeping them on track is one of the challenges, right? So what you do then, you can’t call on every team in a large enrollment class. Let’s say maybe you have 10 or 15 teams in your large enrollment course, but you can randomly call on two or three of them. And the teams don’t know which two or three you’re going to call upon. So they have to be prepared to respond in case their team is called upon.

Now, it’s a good idea to tie that question to the assigned reading for the day. It encourages students to complete the reading ahead of time because of the sense of community that develops from being with the same group of five to eight students throughout the course of the semester. Even if it’s a class of 150 students, students feel like they belong. I have my team, I have my community, we support each other in learning in this course. So there’s this positive peer pressure that develops for students. I need to complete the reading so I can contribute to my team, or I’ll be letting my team down. And that sense of community is important not only for the sense of belonging in your individual classroom, but it helps facilitate learning when students think they belong. And that sense of belonging in community also contributes to things that administrators like me worry about. Will students be retained from one semester to the next semester? It also contributes positively to student graduation rates. So not only are you helping students learn in your course by putting students in a large enrollment class in semester long small groups, but you’re also making it more likely that they’re going to be retained in college, and to graduate.

ACTIVITY PURPOSE

Recognising that discussion is not limited to whole class conversations, but also may occur in dyads or small groups provides opportunities for more shy students to engage without having to speak in front of the entire class. Organising students into teams has the added benefit of creating a sense of community and belonging even when the course has large numbers of students enrolled. This sense of community also creates positive peer-pressure to be prepared for the discussion by completing reading assignments and to engage in the conversation.

See Think-Pair-Share strategy which allows for discussion in a dyad.

INSTRUCTIONS

  1. Instructors assign students to semester-long small group teams of five to eight students. You may want to name teams after famous contributors to the field (e.g., Team Freud; Team Skinner; Team Calkins).
  2. Team members are required to sit close to one another so that during a class session, the instructor may provide a question or topic for discussion in teams. Instructors may want to tie the discussion to assigned readings as a way of encouraging reading compliance. Another strategy that helps ensure discussions are focused and productive is to provide discussion questions prior to class so that students may begin contemplating responses and organising their thoughts.
  3. As teams discuss, the instructor moves around the room listening in on conversation to ensure teams stay on topic.
  4. After an appropriate amount of time, 5 to 8 minutes, the instructor calls the class together again and randomly calls on teams to share their insights. Because teams do not know which team(s) will be asked to report out to the entire class, they are more likely to remain focused on the topic even if the instructor does not wander close by during the discussion. 

 

ADAPTATIONS AND EXAMPLES

Do you have any suggestions? Please share them in the comments below.

RELATED RESOURCES

Do you have any suggestions? Please share them in the comments below.

Watch Video

ABOUT

  • Educator prep: None
  • Duration: 5-30 mins

Do you have an activity that you would like to suggest?

More activities

Course

Leading In-Class Group Work

Webinar recording

Learning Styles: Understanding the Myth and the Opportunity

Resource

A Brief Guide to Effective Mini-Lectures

Resource

3 Techniques for Engaging Students in the Classroom

Video discussion

What Is Active Learning?: An Interview With Derek Bruff

Course

Introduction to Teaching with Zines

Video discussion

Addressing Destructive Behaviour in the Classroom: Interview with Chavella T. Pittman

Course

Climate Action Pedagogy (CAP) Design Challenge

Resource

3 Ways to Encourage Classroom Discussion

Course

Graduate Student Teachers: Starting Strong

Resource

3 Ways to End a Class 

Course

Improving the Student Experience with Exit Tickets

Activity

Are You on TRAC?: Teaching Essential Research Skills

Interview

‘Picture a Professor’: An Interview With Jessamyn Neuhaus

Webinar recording

Using ‘Reflective Pairs’ To Engage Learners

Webinar recording

Creating An Engaged Classroom

Video discussion

Deliberate Dialogue: Discussing Academic Integrity in the Classroom

Course

Fostering Critical Thinking In Discussions

Course

Classroom Practice: Engaged Lecturing

Course

Teaching by Discussion

Activity

Limiting Who Can Speak: Classroom Discussion Strategy

Activity

Think-Pair-Share: Classroom Discussion Strategy

Course

Classroom Practice: Active Learning

Webinar recording

Using Storytelling in Webinars

Top Tips

Tips For Increasing Engagement In Discussions

Activity

Classroom Engagement – 8 Step Model

Course

Introduction to Reflection-Based Activities for Students

Course

An Overview of Classroom Engagement

Course

Using Improvisation in Teaching

Activity

Icebreaker Exercise: The Never-Ending Box

Activity

Taking on a Confident Persona: Exploring Status

Activity

Promoting Collaboration and Positivity

Making Large Classes Feel Smaller: Classroom Discussion Strategy

We’ve mentioned two strategies for engaging students in the college classroom. The use of a Think-Pair-Share, and limiting who can speak. We also want to talk about those large courses. How can you make a large enrollment course feel smaller so that students will engage in classroom discussion? Of course, you can use the strategy in a large class. That makes perfect sense. And then perhaps asking people to volunteer their partner, or randomly calling on pairs of students to speak up. But a better strategy, I think, is to organise students in semester long small groups or teams.

Now a good strategy for this, I’m a sociologist, in my case, we could name the teams after famous sociologists. So there’s Team Marx, and Team Durkheim, and Team Weber, and Team Mills, and so on. So, you know, pick a name, whatever fun sort of thing so students begin to recognise that’s my team. My team has a name. And then there are five to eight students in each of those teams. And in these large enrollment courses, students are required to sit close to one another during class. And while the class might be predominantly lecture because of the large size, at some point or points during the class session, you take a break from the lecture and say, it’s time for us to have conversations in our teams.

So just as with Think-Pair-Share, you give them a compelling question that can be addressed from multiple different angles, and provide different insights. And have the students discuss the question in their teams. Now, keeping them on track is one of the challenges, right? So what you do then, you can’t call on every team in a large enrollment class. Let’s say maybe you have 10 or 15 teams in your large enrollment course, but you can randomly call on two or three of them. And the teams don’t know which two or three you’re going to call upon. So they have to be prepared to respond in case their team is called upon.

Now, it’s a good idea to tie that question to the assigned reading for the day. It encourages students to complete the reading ahead of time because of the sense of community that develops from being with the same group of five to eight students throughout the course of the semester. Even if it’s a class of 150 students, students feel like they belong. I have my team, I have my community, we support each other in learning in this course. So there’s this positive peer pressure that develops for students. I need to complete the reading so I can contribute to my team, or I’ll be letting my team down. And that sense of community is important not only for the sense of belonging in your individual classroom, but it helps facilitate learning when students think they belong. And that sense of belonging in community also contributes to things that administrators like me worry about. Will students be retained from one semester to the next semester? It also contributes positively to student graduation rates. So not only are you helping students learn in your course by putting students in a large enrollment class in semester long small groups, but you’re also making it more likely that they’re going to be retained in college, and to graduate.