How to Put Into Practice
An effective assessment plan provides you with a view into how students are doing and whether or not they are meeting planned learning outcomes. Assessment is not the same as grading: activities or assignments measuring achievement of outcomes may be graded or ungraded, and there is value to using both. When assessments overall are well-aligned with course learning outcomes and activities, they enhance students’ learning and motivation by giving them the tools to adjust their own learning habits, evaluate their own work, and connect to the larger purpose of the course.
A useful approach to developing assessments is to plan, over the duration of the course and/or each unit, to deploy three categories of assessment: diagnostic, formative, and summative.
- Diagnostic assessments provide a quick look into what students know or understand at the start of a period of time (the start of a course, unit, or class session)
- Formative assessments monitor student learning on an ongoing basis with the goal of providing actionable feedback to students and informing instruction
- Summative assessments are designed for students to demonstrate what they have learned at the end of a period of time (the end of a unit or the end of the course)
6.3 Guide to Frequency and Variety offers further explanation of diagnostic, formative, and summative assessments, for each category. Note that these three categories are not mutually exclusive. For example, a summative assessment that takes the form of a research paper involves many component skills—designing a good research question, identifying peer-reviewed sources—that can be broken up into a sequence of checkpoints for diagnostic and formative assessment and feedback.
Developing an Assessment Plan
Here are general practices for reviewing an assessment plan:
Check for alignment. Assessments that look at knowledge or skills that are not well-aligned with observable and measurable course learning outcomes (and the activities and instructional materials sustaining them) lead to frustration and demotivation for instructors and students alike. See ”Where to Start: Backward Design” (MIT Teaching +Learning Lab) or OneHE member resources “Fundamentals of Backward Course Design” and “How to Write Effective Learning Outcomes”. (Access: These resources are available with OneHE membership. A 10-day free trial is available for new members.)
Focus and narrow assessments to what is most critical for students to know or do. For an exam or quiz, this may mean narrowing the exam questions to assess the most critical skills or knowledge. Alternatively, this might mean taking a longer assignment and breaking it into pieces to give each more sustained and focused attention over a longer period of time, without giving many additional assignments during that time to preserve students’ focus. Scaffolding assignments into smaller milestones is also a defense against uncritical AI generation, as it emphasizes the developmental process over a single final product.
Conduct regular and varied assessments. This can mean combining the three assessment categories outlined above (diagnostic, formative, and summative), as well as varying what students will actually do in order to demonstrate their learning. For instance, you can combine formative assessment (to identify gaps and areas for more focus) and summative assessment to check if foundational skills and knowledge are adequately mastered before moving on to a new topic or module in your course.
- Example 1: A group of students are struggling in a homework assignment that lays the foundation for an important skill in the course. This gives you information about where students have gaps and may need additional support or guidance before moving on to more advanced skills.
- Example 2: Conversely, students may be exceeding expectations on an assignment you expected to be more challenging. This may support moving through this skills area more quickly and moving to more advanced skills.
For more strategies and resources in this area, see: 6.3 Guide to Frequency & Variety.
Plan to communicate with students regularly about how the assessments help them achieve the stated learning outcomes. This helps build student motivation and investment in the assignment, activity, or exam.
- The syllabus, module overviews, assignment descriptions, quiz directions, and grading rubrics are key ways to clarify to students how assessments fit into the course as a whole.
- Don’t be afraid to repeat yourself in different places such as syllabus, module overviews or grading rubrics; repeated exposure helps students receive these messages.
- Clearly communicating these expectations early and often helps to promote academic integrity and prevent confusion. See possible approaches and example AI statements (University of Wisconsin-Madison).
Provide transparent instructions and expectations for assignments and exams. If students are supported in understanding what an assignment or exam is designed to do, you can better assess the quality of their work and their progress towards the learning outcomes. For strategies and resources, see “6.4 Guide to Writing Clear Instructions” and “6.5 Guide to Expectations and Feedback”. Learn more with the OneHE member resource ”Transparency in Learning and Teaching”. (Access: This resource is available with OneHE membership. A 10-day free trial is available for new members.)
Facilitate students’ learning from assessments and feedback. Students often fixate on the grade earned instead of the bigger-picture messages assessments can convey (e.g., feedback to apply to future work; study habits to adjust). Here are a few practices to prevent this happening:
- Adjust grading policies weighted heavily towards a few high-stakes assessments.
- Student anxiety and fixation on points reduce when the grading policy encourages them to study and accumulate points regularly, rather than a single grade for a big project.
- Have students reflect on what they learned from completing an assessment.
- To ensure that they don’t view reflections as extra work, such reflection activities require time, space, and intentional framing by you.
- One common framing strategy is to ask students to complete an exam wrapper after receiving an exam score. An exam wrapper is a handout with questions designed to help students identify the study and learning habits that helped or hindered their success on the assessment or exam, with the goal of adjusting their habits. Carnegie Mellon offers several examples of exam wrappers in STEM courses, and tips for using them effectively.